I was playing The Beatles – Hey Jude on Winamp (which then shows on MSN 7.0 or later) when this conversation ensued:
Hey Jude!!
I like Sun Yan Zhi’s version
I heard hers as well, but I prefer the Beatles version… hers is a bit too angelic and pure voiced
Nice maaa
She doesn’t have the part where they go Yeah yeah yaaah yeaahaa WHHOOOOOO! And those intricate harmonies!
ergh
I dunno how to explain.. but I prefer Yan Zhi’s version
Haha okay
I like that particular bit (3:00 onwards) where they go all spazzy and rock and roll-ish
It’s very expressive
ergh
You don’t like that part?
Nope
Painful to the ears
Makes me cringe
*picks you up and puts you on the side of the line of people who don’t like that part*
Aiyo!
I LOVE IT
The fact that the Beatles have a lot of these cuckoo moments is what makes me love them
And the jude-a-jude-a-waaah-aaa-AOOOWWW!
Why do you think Michael Jackson bought the rights to them Beatles songs maaan
coz he got the AOWWW from them, he might be scared that they would sue him
I mean, I like the beginning and the chords and all, but the second half really defines the song for me
At the same time, I think Nelly feat. Kelly Rowland – Dilemma is a &@!#*&@!# annoying song
Especially the high-pitched AUUUW part at the end of each sentence
Kalau takde benda itu, sure orait punya
You can figure that those in italics are what I said.
But seriously man, the fact that they go cuckoo and just lose it makes the Beatles’ version better. Better. Better better better better OH!!!
Which is why I don’t like Mariah Carey. She’s a tonally perfect pitched multi-octaved super singer singing robot. She’s got no SOUL!
I m no big fan of the Beatles but Stephanie Sun totally murdered the song. She’s from Singapore btw =P
HK artists copy cat too much. Dun like ’em.
Copy cat version dun have experession and soul, man. Just like you said.
yea baby…
the beatles rox.
steph sun’s version is .. erm.. not calm la.!! i prefer the beatles wan
you have just incureed the wrath of countless young and hopeful college girls who happen to fans on Ms. Carey. You’re gonna get pwned, man.
I found that her vocals followed all of Paul’s melodic inflections, down to his little off-tuneness. The difference is in her vocal timbre (it’s not fair, Paul has an earnest voice) and the super-clean production ("f***ing hell", among other vocal leaks, can be heard at 2:58 in The Beatles version). Heck, The Beatles have a lot of slipups on record.
I wonder if she was told to cut out the James-Brown-ish improvisation section at the end. Modern audiences wouldn’t care for that.
Syefri: I don’t know about you but I dig the violin bass tone!